Gifts for kids who have everything: ideas for ages 8–12 that aren't more stuff
Buying for a child aged about 8 to 12 whose bedroom is already full? Here's practical advice on gifts they'll actually use, do or share – including a funny book that takes up almost no shelf space.
Full disclosure: this page is written by the team behind Murphy's Law for Kids, so we do mention our own book. The rest of the advice applies whatever you decide to wrap.
Why "has everything" is tricky
By 8 to 12, plenty of children have the console, the craft kits, the Lego and more cuddly toys than shelves. Parents are often quietly hoping nobody adds to the pile. And the child? They tend to remember what they did with a present far longer than what it was.
So the trick isn't to find the one object they don't own. It's to give something that gets used up, gets done, or gets shared – and leaves the bedroom no fuller than it was.
A simple test: will this still be in use in a month, or will it be in a cupboard? If it's the cupboard, keep looking.
Gift ideas that aren't more clutter
These kinds of presents tend to work for 8–12 year olds who already have plenty:
Experiences
A trip to a climbing wall, trampoline park, cinema, match or show. Better still, go with them – the time together is often the part they remember.
A skill or a lesson
A taster class in something they've mentioned: cooking, coding, drawing, a musical instrument or a new sport. Check with a parent first so it fits the family diary.
Things that get used up
Baking ingredients with a recipe card, good art supplies, seeds to grow, or materials for a hobby they already love. Used, enjoyed, gone.
Something for the whole family
A card or board game everyone can play after dinner. One game shared by the household beats three toys played with alone.
An upgrade, not an extra
Replace something worn out with a better version – a proper football, a decent sketchbook, a sturdier water bottle – rather than adding a duplicate.
Something funny to read
A short joke book or humour book they can dip into. It takes up a few centimetres of shelf, gets read straight away and can be passed on to a sibling or friend.
Shopping by exact age instead? See our Christmas guides for 8, 9, 10, 11 and 12 year olds. Want something small? Try stocking fillers for kids aged 8–12.
Five quick rules before you buy
- Ask what's gathering dust. One message to a parent – "What have they gone off, and what do they still use every day?" – tells you more than any wish list.
- Think about space. If it needs a new shelf, a box or a corner of the garden, check first. Small and flat usually wins.
- Favour time over things. An afternoon with you doing something they love often means more than a pricier present.
- Match their age now. Kids in this range notice when a gift is babyish. Aim for what they're into this term, not last year.
- Don't compete on price. A child with lots of stuff won't be impressed by the most expensive box. Thoughtful and fun beats big.
Buying from far away? Our guides to long distance gifts for grandkids and Christmas gifts for nieces and nephews cover shipping and making it feel personal.
Our pick: a funny book for ages 8–12

If you want a gift that won't add to the clutter, Murphy's Law for Kids by Professor Max Murphy is worth a look. It's a humour book of 101 hilariously true rules about why things go wrong at the worst possible moment – the toast that lands butter-side down, the printer that breaks the night before the project is due.
It's written for ages 8–12, and the laws are short, so even kids who "don't like reading" can dip in. It's also a gift they share: most children read one, laugh and then read it out to the nearest grown-up.
Want a taster first? Read 10 sample laws written for this website, or try the free, ad-free Murphy's Law games. Comparing options for a 10 year old? See funny books for 10 year olds.
Get your copy on Amazon
Opens amazon.com in a new tab. Prices, delivery dates and gift options are shown on Amazon.
Several books have similar titles – this one is by Professor Max Murphy with the bright yellow toast-and-egg cover (paperback ASIN B0GS7134BP).
Making a small gift feel big
When a child has lots already, presentation and a personal touch do the heavy lifting:
Add a note
Try: "Murphy's Law of presents: the one thing you don't have is the one thing nobody thinks of. So here's a book of laws instead."
Bundle it
Pair the book with a notebook labelled "My own Murphy's Laws" and a good pen. Kids love inventing laws about their own family – see our write-your-own game.
Add a promise
Tuck in a handwritten voucher for a day out with you. It's the experience gift and something to unwrap, all in one.
Buying for a teenager who has everything too? Murphy's Law for Teens covers school stress, social drama and group chats; Kindle out now, paperback coming soon. For more ideas across the whole 8–12 range, see our full Christmas gift guide for kids 8–12 who "don't like reading".
Questions grown-ups ask
What do you buy a child aged 8 to 12 who has everything?
Something they use up, do or share rather than another object to store: an experience, a class or lesson, craft or baking supplies, a game for the whole family, or a short funny book. Ask a parent what has been gathering dust so you avoid more of the same.
Are experience gifts good for kids who have everything?
Usually, yes. A day out, a workshop or tickets to something they love tends to be remembered long after toys are forgotten. Give something to unwrap on the day too, such as a printed ticket, a handwritten voucher or a small related item, so it doesn't feel like an empty box.
Is a book a good gift for a child who already has lots of things?
A book takes up little space, gets used straight away and can be passed on afterwards. Short, funny books suit this age well because children can dip in, laugh and read bits aloud, even if they wouldn't sit down with a long novel.
Is Murphy's Law for Kids right for a child who has everything?
It is written for children aged 8 to 12. Amazon lists a reading age of 6 to 15. It is a humour book of 101 short laws about why things go wrong, so it works for confident and reluctant readers. Look for the author Professor Max Murphy and the bright yellow toast-and-egg cover.
What if the child is nearly a teenager?
Murphy's Law for Teens covers school stress, social drama and group chats. The Kindle edition is out now and the paperback is coming soon. Our Christmas gift guide for 12 year olds may also help if they are on the cusp.
Join the Murphy's Law club (grown-ups only)
Be first to hear when the Murphy's Law for Teens paperback and new books arrive. Occasional emails, no spam – Murphy's Law says your inbox is full enough already.
For parents, carers and teachers aged 18+. We'll only use your email for book news, and you can unsubscribe any time.